A research and exhibition project on Basel's colonial history at Theater Basel. Provenance research in collaboration with Basel museums (Museum der Kulturen, Natural History Museum) and artists from Indonesia and Sri Lanka.
Research: 2018 - 2019
Exhibition: January - May 2020
Foyer Grosses Haus, Theater Basel, Switzerland
Curatorial team:
→ Vera Ryser
→ Sally Schonfeldt
Supported by: ETH Zurich, SNF Agora Project, The Swiss Arts Council Pro Helvetia, Christoph Merian Foundation, Ernst Göhner Foundation, Aargau Kuratorium
In the name of science, two naturalists from Basel, Fritz and Paul Sarasin, brought back exotic animals, plants, ethnological and archaeological objects, as well as skulls and skeletons from various colonial territories to Basel around 1900. In doing so, they laid the foundation for one of the largest ethnological collections in German-speaking Europe. The history of the Sarasins was comprehensively examined in Bernhard C. Schär's study
Tropenliebe (Tropical Love). Based on this study, Ryser and Schonfeldt initiated a research project focusing on the gaps in the Sarasin collections in Basel and invited artists from Indonesia and Sri Lanka to engage with these objects and their history.
In cooperation with Theater Basel, which produced a play about the lives of the Sarasins, Ryser and Schonfeldt curated an exhibition and mediation project in the theatre's foyer. This resulted in ten different art works by Rahmat Arham, Deneth Piumakshi Veda Arachchige, Julia Sarisetiati, 'Jimged' Ary Sendy Trisdiarto, Angela Wittwer, as well as Ryser and Schonfeldt. All artworks reference and comment on each other within the overarching exhibition structure. Thus, a material and visual world is created in the foyer of the theatre that refers to the colonial connections between Switzerland, Indonesia, and Sri Lanka around 1900, commenting on and critiquing these connections from a polycentric perspective and from various geographical viewpoints. The exhibition is accompanied by a public programme featuring guests from the fields of science, art, and education.
Research by Vera Ryser and Sally Schonfeldt
The point of departure for
Voices from an Archived Silence is the colonially acquired
collections of two major museums
located in Basel — one in the Museum der
Kulturen (MKB), the other in the Natural History
Museum (NMB). In particular it revolves
around local Basel-born Swiss natural
scientists Fritz and Paul Sarasin who contributed
significantly to both museums’ collections.
Both are also closely intertwined
with the foundational histories of the two Basel
museums, not to mention being intimately
involved with numerous other important
cultural institutions in Basel. Fritz Sarasin
was the founding Director of the Museum für
Völkerkunde (today’s Museum der Kulturen)
in 1918, he was also the Director of the Natural
History Museum from 1899 to 1919. The
Sarasins both came from wealthy Basel patrician
families and obtained scientific degrees
from prestigious European universities.
Their considerable wealth afforded them
the ability to self-fund their scientific collecting
expeditions in colonially occupied countries
at the turn of the 19th century.
See more
Inspecting the skin of a Cui-cui bird at the Ornithological Collection of the Natural History Museum in Basel in 2019, this specimen was collected by the Sarasins in Sulawesi in 1903. The bird was named Zosterops sarasinorum after its alleged discoverers. While the bird was already known to the local population as the Cui-cui bird, we have not found this name documented in any of the Sarasins' sources. Photo: Flavio Karrer
This card catalog at the Photo Archives of the Museum of Cultures in Basel contains several hundred images from Sri Lanka, primarily anthropometric photographs taken in the service of early race studies. These images dehumanize and categorize people from different ethnicities and are likely some of the first photographs taken on the island, with some dating back to 1883. The photo archive is not public, and the catalog is not available online on the museum's website.
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Interior image of one of the Museum of Culture’s
off-site collection storage facilities, 2019. The infrastructures makes visible just how much
expense, effort and care is needed to preserve and conserve such collections. What would have happened to these objects if they hadn’t been stored here?
Photo: Sally Schonfeldt
In the Anthropological Collection of the Natural
History Museum human remains from both Basel and all over the world are stored. It is one
of the Museum’s most sensitive collections as the provenance of many of the human remains
is still unclear. In colonial contexts human crania and skeletons were “collected” from local
populations, often using dubious methods. Such research was conducted within a context of scientific racism.
Photo: Flavio Karrer
The map shows Fritz and Paul Sarasin’s travel route during their expedition
on the island. Revisiting their expeditions reports was crucial for us in understanding their research in colonial spaces.
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Whilst tracing the origin and exhibition history of the Vedda exhibition figures we came across this scenario. It was set up for production of postcards. Our faces are reflected in the image, transposed over the exhibition figures.
Ruminating over our own fascination for processes of “Othering.” Are we doing the same?
Photo: Sally Schonfeldt
Fritz and Paul Sarasin’s plate camera. We reflected on this historical lens, which the two scientists used to take photos of local populations in Sri Lanka and Sulawesi, including racist anthropometric photos. In front of this camera the Sarasins staged supposedly
“primitive Natives,” capturing them for Western audiences.
Photo: Vera Ryser
Exhibition views
Theater Basel, 2020.
Photo: Flavio Karrer
See more
Theater Basel, 2020.
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Theater Basel, 2020.
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Theater Basel, 2020.
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Theater Basel, 2020.
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Rahmat Arham, Angela Wittwer:
Dan Dia Bilang Gitu – The Past Is Still Processing, 2019
Still: the artists
The work stems from an investigation into Colliq Pujié (1812–1876),
a writer and anti-colonial Sulawesi intellectual and mother of Queen We Tenri Ollé (?–1919),
whose dynasty ruled over parts of Sulawesi
at the time of the Sarasins’ expedition. Pujié
actively instigated resistance against the
Dutch colonial powers by means of a codified secret language that she distributed in
the form of sureqs, or oral poems, and which
incited local populations to rise up against
their colonizers. The audio-visual work brings Pujié’s
voice of resistance into the present.
Deneth Piumakshi Veda Arachchige:
136 Years Ago and Now, 2019
Photo: Flavio Karrer
“My works are inspired by a personal desire,
as a Sri Lankan, to set the record straight and
to defy the indifference of Fritz and Paul Sarasin’s
scientific expedition to Ceylon in 1883.
Going beyond reductive categorizations of
people and intrigued by their writings and
expeditions, I decided to follow in their tracks
136 years later.“
See more
“Like them I travelled with a
camera, but the most important objects I carried
with me were copies of old photographs
taken by the Sarasins’ themselves. These images
of my ancestors from Sri Lanka were
part of a forgotten colonial past. So my goal
was to bring them out of the dusty box of
archived history and let the images speak by
bringing them back to light, recapturing their
portraits
in a contemporary Sri Lankan environment.
The photographs were highlighted
and brought into focus the past, while also
showing the surrounding present, blurred, at
a distance.
Whilst in Sri Lanka, I conducted interviews
with Sinhalese, Tamil and Aadivasin
(Veddas). Today some Aadivasin live in difficult
conditions. The impact of land-seizures,
economic development projects, and years
of civil war, has marginalized them once
again. Back in Basel I interviewed members
of the Sri Lankan diaspora (since the 1990s,
Switzerland is home to 30,000 to 40,000 Sri
Lankan Tamil who left the country during the
long civil war) and listened to their views on
the photo and object archives that are kept
in the Museum of Cultures in Basel, Switzerland.
It was important for me to include their
contemporary voices and reactions. For these
audio-visual works, I also interviewed people
in the Museums of Basel, Colombo, Dambana
and Paris and added filmed visuals of Basel
architecture related to the Sarasins and their
family.“
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Deneth Piumakshi Veda Arachchige:
Beginning of You, Me and Others, 2019
Photo: Flavio Karrer
“‘The Parisian colour chart’ was created by
Paul Broca, the founder of the Paris Anthropological
Society. He had specifically created
a skin colour chart for the Sarasins according
to their needs in dividing the people of Ceylon
into different races during their scientific
expedition in the 1900s. The colours were
grouped into Vedda Men skin colours, Vedda
Men chest colours, Vedda Women skin colours,
Vedda Women breast colours, Tamil
Men skin colours, Tamil Men chest colours,
Tamil Women skin colours, Tamil Women
breast colours, Singhalese Men skin colours,
Singhalese Men chest colours, Singhalese
Women skin colours & Singhalese Women
breast colours. At some point this colour
chart was not enough for dividing the people
examined and the Sarasins had to extend the
colours of the original chart. For this work I
decided to select three colours from the original
Sarasinian skin colour chart used to represent
Vedda, Tamil and Sinhalese people.“
Deneth Piumakshi Veda Arachchige:
Sensitive Expedition, 2019
Photo: Flavio Karrer
“During my expedition to Sri Lanka I also documented
the environmental and economical
changes that have occurred since the Sarasins’
journey to Ceylon. I collected objects
from the Vedda community, as well as some
sample materials from each village area,
such as earth and rocks. Mirroring the Sarasins’
historical collection of ethnographic and
skeletal material during their expeditions to
Sri Lanka, I have installed a contemporary
re-enactment of this practice of collection in
the vitrines in the Foyer of the Theater Basel.“
See more
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Deneth Piumakshi Veda Arachchige:
Voices of the Ancestors, 2019
Photo: Flavio Karrer
In her work
Voices of the Ancestors, Deneth Piumakshi Veda Arachchige
actively subverts and repeals the scientific
racism that led to the production of three
Vedda exhibition figures in the MKB collection
by producing a contemporary 3D version
of them, based on her own self. In doing so,
she not only reflects on the violent racialized
“othering” practices embedded in the figures’
construction, but also on the contemporary
legacy of racist practices. In reclaiming
the position for herself of someone who
would have historically been “othered” she
offers us a poignant subversion.
See more
“Ceylon? Sri Lanka? Where is it? Who lives
there? Who are these Ceylonese people? Are
they a “primitive disappearing race?” Should
they be called a “race” or “varieties” of people?
I found during my research that files and
images marked “Ceylon” at both the Basel
and Paris National Archives were misplaced,
some being in an Africa folder of the archive
and others mixed in with images of Samoa,
New Caledonia or India. During my first visit
to the archive of the Natural History museum
in Basel, I was invited to see the remains of
Aadivasin (people formerly known as Vedda).
After putting on blue plastic gloves, I had the
opportunity to hold the skull of this ancestor
and this experience moved me deeply. His
skull was among dozens of unethically removed
human remains that were dug up by
the Sarasins during their time in Sri Lanka
and brought to Europe. I did not know why
he had ended up halfway across the world in
a plastic box, however I felt an unexpected
connection. The sculpture aims to pay respect
to all my uprooted ancestors and to
their disregarded way of life, so in tune with
nature yet so easily trivialized in this fastpaced
world. Instead of reproducing the image
of someone who had no say in the taking
of their image, as in the case of the Sarasins’
photographs, in which several people clearly have marked expressions of fear, confusion,
and alienation, I decided to use my own
body as the basis for the sculpture.”
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Duo Ryser+Schonfeldt:
Counter Library, 2019
Photo: Flavio Karrer
The library is conceived of as a concentrated
space that offers visitors a chance for indepth
reflection on the Swiss colonial entanglements elaborated on in the exhibition.
Through the provision of a curated selection
of both contemporary and historical literature
the library acts as a counter-space, in
which an alternative reading of Swiss history
is offered. Books can be consulted on-site
or copied to take away.
See more
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Duo Ryser+Schonfeldt:
Practicing the Othering, Part 1, 2019
Photo: Flavio Karrer
How have practices of “othering” traditionally
functioned? One historical strategy in
ethnographic museums was the production
of racialized stereotypical exhibition figures
used to represent a certain “race” of people
often deemed “primitive” in the logic of the
late 19th century up until the mid 20th century.
Fritz and Paul Sarasin used this logic in
the production of three plaster exhibition figures
depicting Vedda people that they commissioned
for display in the Völkerkunde Museum
(today’s Museum der Kulturen) in Basel
in the early 20th Century. Ryser+Schonfeldt
reverse and reconfigure this “othering” gaze
on the Sarasins themselves. By producing 3D
copies of two busts, which stand in the lobby of
Basel’s Natural History Museum honouring
Fritz and Paul Sarasin, Ryser+Schonfeldt demand
an urgent self-reflection from today’s
Swiss society in confronting historical and
contemporary forms of “othering.”
See more
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Duo Ryser+Schonfeldt:
Practicing the Othering, Part 2, 2019
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Two historical display vitrines offer a fictionalized
imaginary of Fritz and Paul Sarasin’s
everyday life in Basel around 1900 as a counterpoint
to the history of their scientific expeditions
to colonially occupied Indonesia and
Sri Lanka. In the vitrines, which were historically used in museum displays constructing
ethnographic views of exoticized “Others”
at the Museum für Völkerkunde (formerly
Museum der Kulturen), Ryser+Schonfeldt
subvert a Swiss “othering,” gaze and turn it
back on itself. Through an assemblage of objects,
images and documents attesting to
colonial presences in Basel, such as Tea tins
advertising with racial depictions of colonized
subjects, juxtaposed with the wealthy
interiors of Fritz and Paul Sarasin’s Basel
abode, the vitrines provoke a critical reflection
on those collecting, rather than on those
being collected. Grounded in ideas of critical
whiteness and the need for white Swiss society
to self-reflect on its own significant role
in colonial enterprises, Ryser+Schonfeldt
turn the mirror around with their fictionalized
display. In doing so the duo asks what a museum
display of ourselves and our own practices
of exoticizing “Others” might look like?
See more
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Duo Ryser+Schonfeldt:
The Entangled Histories of Three Exhibition Figures and a Bird, 2019
Photo: Flavio Karrer
What could an object lying in a museum
storeroom tell us about itself and all the different
contexts it has been entangled in, if it
could tell us its own story? Using this question
as a foundation for a two year long archival
research in two of Basel’s museum
collections, the Natural History Museum and
the Museum der Kulturen, Ryser + Schonfeldt
have created two so-called Object Biographies.
Selecting an individual object from
each collection, a preserved bird from the
Natural History Museum and a pair of lifesize
exhibition model figures from the Museum
der Kulturen, the duo shows the different
colonial entanglements encircling each object.
On two large-scale stage curtains and
accompanying museum boards intervening
in the existing architecture of the Foyer, the
two objects biographies offer a comprehensive
selection of both primary and secondary
archival images and texts. By situating each
object’s trajectory within a complex field of
trans-local networks, the colonial provenance
of the two objects, as well as the museum
collections themselves, are revealed.
Julia Sarisetiati, 'Jimged' Ary Sendy Trisdiarto:
A Possibility of Owning Other's Text, 2019
Photo: Flavio Karrer
In Sarisetiati
and Trisdiarto’s video works,
A Possibility of
Owning Other’s Text, Colliq Pujié’s sureqs are performed
and re-sung in the present by a group
of local workers at the Sulawesian port of
Parepare. Parepare is significant today as a
site of numerous resistance struggles against
precarious labour conditions as well as of
contemporary Indonesian (undocumented)
migrations to Malaysia in search of employment.
By actualizing local voices of historical
resistance the work embeds a defiant
continuum of resistance and anti-colonial
struggle at the port, countering Western historiography
with its Indonesian counterpart.
See more
“The work begins with a conversation amongst
seven people about one of Colliq Pujié’s
sureqs—a poem to be sung— that is relatable
to our daily resistance, be it towards the
governmental system, global economy or
class struggles. They come from different
professions: scholars, fishermen, labourers,
mothers, youngsters, businesswomen, and
unemployed. They rehearsed singing it and
eventually performed a sing-along of the
sureq. Coming from the mid 19th century,
Colliq Pujié was a noble woman who wrote
letters to her peers encouraging them to keep
on resisting colonialism. Fascinated with the
direct relationship between text and (the act
of) resistance, the work tries to formulate an
embodiment, a form of ownership, of the text
within our contemporary realities. Gathering
these heroes of everyday-life, along with their
various resistance qualities, the work was
made in the Port of Parepare, a landmark
for
different struggles surrounding the precariousness
of labour and working conditions.
During the Torajan civil war, the losers had
to become slaves and were hence traded
through this port. During the Dutch times, the
colonial government’s forced plantation act
was also dependent on trades happening
through this port. Today, the port has a reputation
for being the exit gate for Indonesian
migrant workers wanting to reach Malaysia,
particularly those who are undocumented,
hence illegal. It is almost as if resistance is an
embedded mood at the Port of Parepare.“
Photo: Flavio Karrer
Interview with Sulaiman Mangulin, Priest and Community Leader of Tana Toraja. Still: the artists
Interview mit Ahmat Saransi, Regional archivist in the Department of Archives and Library of South Sulawesi Province. Still: the artists
Interview mit Anwar Toshibo, Lecturer in the Department of Archaeology at Hasanudding University, Makassar. Still: the artists
Reviving an old poem (sureq) by Colliq Pujié with locals in the Port of Parepare. Still: the artists
Still: the artists
Still: the artists
Still: the artists